File systems

File systems have been around for centuries, with punching cards and magnet tape being among the earliest vari­a­tions. However, these devices only allowed for linear access, for example, a coiling mechanism of the magnet tape to find the storage location of data. Modern file systems enable direct and fast access to data. But what are file systems? And which types of file systems exist?

Different standard file systems are available for Windows, macOS, Linux, Unix, and co. Due to technical advances in the past few years, these systems are now dif­fer­en­ti­at­ed even more as custom-built file systems have been developed for popular flash storage media (USB sticks, SSD drives). Among the features that all file systems share is their tree-like structure, starting at the root from where the system branches out into different folders, sub-folders, and di­rec­to­ries.

Nowadays, there are many different file systems but not many of them are widely spread. The most common systems include FAT16, FAT32, exFAT, and NTFS (Windows), as well as HFS+ and APFS (macOS/Mac OS X). Linux currently uses ext4 (a successor of ext3 and ext2). Below, we’ll present these file systems in brief:

The FAT file system has been around since 1980. Updated editions are known as “FAT12,” “FAT16,” and “FAT32.” FAT for­mat­ting is ideal for the man­age­ment and exchange of smaller data volumes. The FAT file system is now seen as somewhat outdated because even the latest version (FAT32, launched in 1997) only allows for the exchange of data files up to 4 GB in size. Ad­di­tion­al­ly, maximum partition sizes are re­strict­ed to 8 terabytes (TB) with FAT32.

Despite these re­stric­tions, FAT for­mat­ting is still in regular use. For example, it is used with mobile data carriers (external hard drives, USB sticks) and spe­cial­ist hardware (digital cameras, smart­phones, routers, TVs, car radio, etc.), allowing for maximum com­pat­i­bil­i­ty.

The 2006 format is an extension of the classic FAT for­mat­ting. exFAT was orig­i­nal­ly created for external data carriers and is well-suited for USB sticks, storage cards, and external hard drives like solid state drives (SSDs) with in­di­vid­ual storage ca­pac­i­ties. exFAT works ef­fi­cient­ly with smaller data storage media. However, it can handle large data and extend beyond the FAT32 limit of 4 GB. As of Windows 7, exFAT is supported natively, requiring no ad­di­tion­al driver in­stal­la­tion or special service packs.

The NFTS file system was in­tro­duced in 1993 as part of Windows NT. As of Windows Vista, it has become a standard file system for Windows PCs. It provides a few sig­nif­i­cant ad­van­tages compared to FAT, including the option to compress data carriers and increased data security (through en­cryp­tion, for example). A special feature of NTFS is that access rights and clearing of data and files can be defined in great detail. Users can share rights for local and remote access via a network.

The file system was launched in 1998 as an extension of HFS by Apple. To dis­tin­guish between the two, they are referred to as Mac OS Extended (HFS+) and Mac OS Standard (HFS). Compared to HFS, HFS+ is faster and more efficient when it comes to managing, reading, and writing data. In addition, it can manage multiple data at the same time, with up to four million blocks of data or folders possible. Linux is able to read and write data carriers with HFS+ directly, but you may need to install special packages (hfsutils, hfsplus, hfsprogs). When using Windows, you need to install ad­di­tion­al software to support HFS+.

APFS, the file system launched by Apple in 2017, caters to the demands of modern solid state drives (SSD). APFS is a 64-bit system enabling the en­cryp­tion of data and files. If the operating system is on a SSD, HFS+ au­to­mat­i­cal­ly converts the file system to APFS. This “auto-for­mat­ting” was in­tro­duced with the High Sierra operating system. As of macOS 10.14 Mojave, fusion drives (logical drives con­sist­ing of SSDs and me­chan­i­cal hard drives) are au­to­mat­i­cal­ly migrated to APFS. When con­vert­ing from HFS+ to APFS, problems can arise.

ext4 was in­tro­duced in 2008 as a successor to ext3. The file system is currently a standard among many Linux systems (e.g. Ubuntu). Its latest addition is the Extents feature, which optimizes the man­age­ment of larger data and ef­fi­cient­ly prevents frag­men­ta­tion compared to its pre­de­ces­sor. As part of ext4, par­ti­tions can be maximized or minimized while the system is running. The maximum data system size is 32 TB in ext3; for ext4, this has been extended to 1 exabyte (around 1 million TBs).

When choosing how to format a system (for example, to use an external hard drive across different computers and devices), com­pat­i­bil­i­ty is of the utmost im­por­tance. For increased flex­i­bil­i­ty while trans­fer­ring data between Apple and Windows devices, for­mat­ting using the exFAT data system is rec­om­mend­ed. The right choice of for­mat­ting of the data carrier is important and can prevent problems and re­stric­tions during data exchange.

Once the core re­quire­ments are met (for example, latest hardware), you can change the system any time, for example, from an older to a more modern file system. However, you should check whether the change may lead to a loss of data and ensure that important data are backed up and can be copied back onto a data drive later. Various programs are available for these transfers (including freeware), which offer a secure and easy con­ver­sion. However, in some instances you may be able to use your operating system instead. Find out more about for­mat­ting the file system of a USB stick in Windows in our dedicated article.